HWP Document File V3.00 7R":NN aA ᢅ(ҁ)G)ccccaAᐂ ᬅ()1999e 1 29 qa, 20 9Wpe3  (J&`rA\uYhqvAuUw42{3ZR[GLR;dH虤LpEw-V^CUnظ\սM'tUN%ޟ+%YAO_KBtxQ}iP8RMZ,oIto_}sg/rNH4륳p 깠:Q}(wQf QD gf=6[U%zѧw}0BhǽDO-'Z}?ђB&!x- #zClA<+fꈪ~zeu*U8.RW* ^qw FVk~+ھz [*olU-l`H]jm{MG Uy*ܶTVըQk*Cۏg.`E981d-: '3!ߤחtEeeΏgg#}֚ f"вC"iC:zQǎ:O,fgtumxzμBڸF2#)?DMDSfc8ׇHOik[*a:̦Mr,pUxW-UغV[| Q]Eڹ QU;eTHYԁ^Q[q1a6i2SoLS/V(i SoP#IL-әݨt`S(?$5fE]Ծ[$x S)8AwyU Ncj쟱eAN+q^l(ュJޜ%g >zfy#c+Ii>`S7{sx}_ Q%38:M %O O.4渄c"0;τ{ū5ߩ˰LNkkh ɠgiߠ+U9avMke2 &x*ʈoj˘_ zdAʒƞ 3-5Q-Tb|[JKh ^UNQV¹D5'k9uSi1?$x{۪mh%̌",p љF,A()_A/E8&=4*i-`4k+= f7".}Dwck¤}KT:'DNuQegfkYu υ_:Lj&؊XP-B[l<'8IH"='3,f0|ؚ4i@É8jP: [cN,JvXlSKvۧ9]Φz#ni͂}Fy~REe &gzFY_AHG!UDگ'3|}fc @u+Q\w}z',$zm1KˈvKr-y(h8:Wu'6=PGTh ThQQT'V TTĪ~FW3QPQ9OrEt~7AQ`a6X-L3IQ'72MVTmp"Sp dVQ_1u/nuг(/DžJ3ϩw%HE(U :˗vɱKVq|;~O>鲵XBܠJ3PB_-aV 1AKt=+b.6.l:FMRV~e(»wl=ف}2&Ibj>-!m!U~Fg?/N0xr E(#7M4eّԭX<ک}:ڏaog9ꔞIJMQ ͲFcSWd8;WOs.`˝RVCvLܖl 3,VKxRff=9oeZ2(Ҧ:_sÚ>lP+XYV *ܫԼjEz8܈noyUÝ(L8Xه  D4s1E/C3#` 6f=oxn/ s:*ݡsH`]+ua8o{FN=?-K5VZ9@M" ;+;a`V?xSd;"6k}P FOy{!6|R PI2m&A|cl ;wZ_ F[5^l-d[]18p 1v~Gph'Ut48Q9M>ӠA=fNT>4wqzx3C[*M;>Otd!k^ZF^hɃDUD}lj6=:D_JeGscXU-a)Yzs&1u{j^ T3UydMu*bꆛ5?)t LuRXAkߐb|(X4T,LK}U})(O|~sEtٚ?$/5ctg5=hmj"q&G`7'|B+$B{s}S_tqj #,s/:qE{fJr CjYja|vY?N3h"{*#lAg >xָ('3wS| %*oUZ~}@N:֕W1搇D,-q bTߋf@# v6k'aE9~zM5zJ;ZH-[K:^|;WtJ 8L7FwEU7>17) ~*~-{+fzդ}8q&Ecؽj΋[b =?d3V5 )v~ye=[W+D]غY/&>{I6N˸F 70hɑP\ypa{>|;?zX59RZMڍVoLq2۹u RQ5v̬-x5> V3D:S LqeC^ '^案Amdk4C.j6zFٝx9d>λcpBX!QͧpѠv HZfw˴ME$dl/&GўRe+xkjUҝ`Ҏ'Pd[2ܜ20y=-GL| 6t3t%IFy P[]NNu%IgNim`&>c6c&2Jµ`LT¾ Q2FK}oѳJSRCK?s"|p`x8wG,_eY@K@F o֟ ܜ5@,G +F\֤NKFNe-}-[,tѪRKT**ȹf%pbiZS 荱LOQ4 Zvwˎ\R{w=h%\{vWD1tbHz3sv]zNIXYIvќau;51ά HJNX.VDA;gM.$}0fP;V}X,h(^p3ڋ3`LD7iѤI~͵/8@Wݨɝ4sTk[&߬Mdj-Jߊ}!=b\҇,+/>X>\}bB69Yv,BP++@-+[b]'Sj,Jtb.)f.I󋩖*"M Yi=Yk9íCm hF"QhqŵZN(,U!rxϿV?Wմ3@`B}R..l==`&H k|կP5G2'HuE#kvr`t L]nͩG ʬZ)QvTdu*icO8*-ϛp7''?)>TV\"!T% /+-|FB2K6*]\}&U TNmPGhhLY+C٭fG BJz׽DYouE$NMtuTwCT)ȎH?m"0fm.$թv"1x״lc+ܾ_*RCo05ײ"3Y豕I5kp pٍ._{'ϸ~أۺP7+Š+Pp;R઺81t;KA=(|c?U4oW?Պzal*j_CuHَVIǪߖ)H9Q$m> Lgj$EUV'<,g]I(_5xp1}mES O&%Ws' i?+ޒ)3Tj8ĉ!Y@O*^,}ܧ+mtj8cG" ~DbqM,'}rnhvq/d=ٯ|6`Qcg$11&W庅'#>jXQ#r3rʌ[~̌ZrƼD1 >c2pʼRw{Ӝ)pCeF}jvLuMZdT{4 ] Yn/,cB^Z.CAԠo8]qx ZcEt=ڪ.A\.EU` <ڍOҪO5'ϪzH}R eF#4¿jytFsV=Y}J|g'pl[N d?ӑUg" 8o;off+RՑ+FV2PM,M:'gTqi\Zx'KEA征RxQ8PK廣Dϑ|Ќc&Y) ]CٚXaM`KNWu_j_&֯4T |]!W 4^]Vm:'C5f-{@%\wqn}1jW#v@AD,jw7\}<9HnsKqh;#ͪCZnWDJ;q $3"ܭ%CCP=B`A9|,UL7 XT3iŃ]ndh\ Ok;dD4r7fu bb4f{]W=Q ?!jN.ΞJtcK;TTZHoݻB@}HAdjζdb*p1̷\! ApxrnXZIUÖ́O12)y1^ qLD>#KuyWr&}o>Ën Q9EWj_/':x[7ZK'o#z5$O4u=o7}QD;CD=J-xT1yޟUƍetɨ9/]eW?H顴G+fÕn'E$c :T) /g>y^Z.YG2\y;A浲~>kWz{&y[ lu0 xتןg?ڛ`] P܄FwYL_;f0{ľbʩބ1♬^{d8Kڛ%/eY$2J^߄g1Ko>I^0$/eh|ԟd>$O(qS<3b8S<=pr{+V~;ѣJy-N뿹+tZh{c*'}IyTlY9h3|M='wHyUy53ڐ F>d59UVV4ɚW3hs_ Ae~xWp+|-VzNK{Ss280R|9>!g1C0zqsV)A,匨k Bb=H۶P"Oƹ FwqN#F=8dӨLY(4OP )R8VoMeGf+i>糥@EKت#VY̷LnZVnX4O9lM[ 782_B]z]_zb<{i_^)?i/0@J]gt^7(S*(ͅY5ۘPNƕ3NUZ~n`Җ^Z;wb=g7V)s<4-54BF"pXۤ}4'ɈiS3f^BZTYQ tWucUj 2j\Rh4w[1^fĎykuBڻX]݈5ֻyq4SGqo18V1l͊1=b$p `߀bȵc ;eV88U6vF'l )pjFGZx lŚң[Q8SD6,A>ՔߐFJJU;DjF*9hX9^7FlT lhD`P]xcg2K ,[B>M`E1/=w\ڠ̗D#*wA0]wVԌ2nuf-n$ʲd'̷aTN?bW~wMX?&(Cbc_ko6[uZo[7+ü^)VbUb}ٚZ_o xhX7rIyK |kф%[g09:?Ub:ʧn󅞋`l 1O:XƕM(%#4o$:E/@;Us}h0)Wezi(| ?;f4Vw ѸYj 7XYQ"ˉ^];[xAQ qʧl&_3% cp!#j1xV5^A[`ާ-llr Gtr'2=x3),t;zݔzŴk"x2R)p :F ~өcxj։uhضVځqi눟V `{?UcuӨ4  7 F.[rqNɽ SLr랟[9ԡ37܌} Bs,@3>5u1>F^GG aڍ}w-xbFr2|?}^!aBKjHAM3q_#YAsfI,K7泵ح.qZ7䭣t4z9>~VYP0vun㴫U /~EqyU^v XQ.\(t ՜fDQU=I Xz.o(i ~ds솒&f!1έj'٨jM|#20L$U{LX#^Jz7?ȗΫ$~j`Q݊^r'=٢}URe"')ItJj7c[/:P+@O 0=1jɺzP},ݟ<3ie!&3k' $lPrt ,l=wX9Sakbü{Bg-Rg=zw[?#֯GĚ: }>WՓf<gP,Z 9?4e Z?d7eh{d(B,e C~$~a;* X )r<1#@}XT<0y[g|T+(2aPNKc-[h_eehvRͭ&c_c0>;?,&%z-)1bNn Z}!gym}9wuS'Ԓ9ćo}ROVtsLK ib>vUǵA^C̆P-삱lJn90Z.WҍpX85S\Ɏ=N.b;;JGZhCF]偑VTFJi3frfͩ`q*5VJ#brH 9kKT89]pj3$OuIjy'߆D(&I{;>秵7fZ4:̭ȸF>zPS]>bJqG}^5-;G;|O.ʘɴ[(*joZ$|(M[,_}X?Kغ/ֿF'X|^^ZP> >(k[vC{؟9が BϱBjG ndV1w`Bqx:wr{p5a+35&(mt7Gw޸ ݣl¼m Nˁ|Oݺ<+:±U{+Sm<c2C!1]ap~H#jF \&G~ת9{)/.O}InxgɖA9U2~ w$qhoD@P0_:ꩉ D<<ŅU8@nheCEce]IJ617d䘙dZRȞMتs˪*UWȮuWwә$$Z{t*{{cb?a y!v?o7r<~9xekiWEzP}Ǣ+n|؜Q4o #3~pq%%o ۸**XgUR,qHcH1\ʹ B&qhDn wq|C ^Gj3RLl뵖TE!),H^zK%V><ߏ2KCQ M3nH=vwE@uQ+n0kRH,-e DTa@RvNR䐠!)h9L<3[+L-;8u:4T2u4AyoMF ؜SǬ Vd|ѩaO(j\,M_$>{DwEWe>yt{nUsgUɡ9e\fq"%6x*<Ƌ4PM RϨtO,^V~5̿0YNLEН~66>|+:'S|.6+01tW}g;`qgf_5ڵ0fFcgx1CF wf[lq8Ǡ4?Z rdCf,~GѨ츃(N]=!IhMA-ٜr U7oJ2v9C;|gj}b#F Pbhg4fk]V1Uj/H֨yyM i yDϠ1EECYL#䄿H}>mmt#"IM5 sޫi6anS%Ex*bb^ZCm +vMUVoyz%6:by+m2q Z^i7z?Ļ<dzKkoۭ^_ct?mgf~'^ Krqa<&m/`&^AuI#P|F>tjZcD;3R{1f  xJMtB;SysʏNAgalzN{gق ﵍ru:,ۇ3](6 YJ5!p\OT\`pywD磼Mgm4edKVWΩcU{>Ҍfiխ퀮Ty| s:MX,\VsRנre vجb<<%Q?-ẋnr#La{inSB Oo+* {ơpřahpI&vk*sa~)P)o*RfA). qHzq1 jZTHe|w8UJuu?&Ƿnb"B"e*iߪigKE{ei VI\btkTm oh_wSV+hvJ =v~٭*cY;n5P7P^#jAd?#LBAguS~)p6 D!{;":N| }= FRp&3nUQ!:=>n.Q|P2gYC@4:14]qA̰Q}=f ʴlҴ-J)>@DD7һ?ʻH`ƒg]xFì%kXZ#va O(:"hpVBAq%(#}"ƔƼb7%bdE-aZe[ Rх*-dC09QQ,78dP[Ƥ pVkJ" d 3t 9{E5]`317zXW !:=unsxLɧ8xXzy4qKlԙ?l+˿0aKʡ:qEP\u+K3n|͹EWy J YHM׳"ݮpUUX[%͡_CvG'ӕ4X/Lw\,_SQNp]jQl"QoVY\1ĎZ)〿5'L1c?)Q#}r,e\ J cqf;6-^Ŧ7s @/,[uӨW;˦ fu^EJ ѤQ5g,)ckb"ˈj+^D]OTy[~{/7|F=;%ZhՃD O]I4Q߬&SDHFT zzѲۉziЊ`Qa4R!AY 1n~]&h4eZ|wNv*_cSs9.Uxr[\t[贕G< &.7'T;Ǡ R+l㧆"oy/U<3,a-|HP=̣jFyōZIW-!j,[o9HwO(gg!k$@ji&k6VCcΘjvix !.jMr>hm||#hhIWͲ)ңӒzk,K=z^.j#\3Qqe[zհ}UpK-osYQyxc r+펆oxݒ1`Hk(=<^vz:##6*(ٛlEh8\oQ+i'18yR0D x^*wZ%Y#Ϛ F4zW;˦)$5_^f~G%cZ;e.&r_FTˌ+dNzD7M跷rsY@g{/!Z yWMx7~D/Dhv^bXTtMqB,՘PU ]үDz$=7r|ht|rfZo,obpq=Qh04odHtݭr L`דMuV+6Z=ф*R{y.hUX\]k]Q; j#N_ haDWoFBT ( +!yS{|t+I'Ildǐv@[ Jh![ee#FKt{+LOҕ,eou˜lҌEO*gɹE ϥ,<װYH=Yzvx.a鎙"ԃݏrCs Ks СAiI^-4jl&IfI מS lUP IљRLWA1j Hޯh$a늣vWSҟ2q楅t/sKz벵H6mH"{ A52Vw~2/mMPTyh5Q<5Ah;\yDO Eӟ4}H(.`$wxXjUrj-+ רlr6(E\@!3st ]FSMf(BVA4 Sha-g )nJkκXU<{OnwM"QJs=}yWd?MF6L=@=fֈO|#w'ΠQRO6ԓ<9@Iy$ő9I|֑w%鎼c|0*Z@1/E1͊S,;Dȟ]Q%:ecr1s%'ܕUp`iAml?gPSt-q~|Op_ڹ`vk2KuKBCw}%ӅMrZ))`.Üf )UO JPvX*P,+G/w~ś/J\41Os~gxS'!#H\yxK޹g*Yq'mTcvU$}!AMsRBb3r?qV,BA 3I"`!<܌u.utUQzLGaŨzn ݅Y:z4:*h\C7bI.޶ǪE;S4~[A{bh&ԵUSf m :Sܣo#;լنŢo`տP4>~ aet]C} 'cxChj{øWDcD)ˉ8@lm/~g0 M;}9~ymMw_t{t!m5gvSJFfy`NuKTC<46&?a-k~NFlKݛQޕmA`4ߑ <{J{2/H6Mto׌}{&BO:(0ߛNOӁ.&Qa[C 0V>'A}Zw_'xsAcdTSLis.)M}r"vdw{U̝xo!u=3@FD>]8'A71 `ǥ]y=EsڱĮ㙄oyޏz!c^g wO4rpI*w8!c1 8})18"~QqCmco2<1Z# _W^5 !hntō:rwIÛ[(6 8rWvrLd 1 +VdPՊEnNcU][,f~>6&5Y&*{ #MU1mbf Շ<e^O*G3O{}"F1AۈT F{M=pMYM␚[݅wR#NoO{3WZm U ӕ?>2(.rʔ?cr*Dfx,/ ׈&TKrO# &>Wa!M.I_X?nODK&ѓ&߻0blc ch 9 wD#[dN.P򉎚-BF1J۠V[-1_߫e5 xk]JXS-Bw<ꝭNfJ2ܻ3dݡ;T:[`Cf~> .Ȍf 7QJ Z "䓮,,~ЮTTHUFTTXwؗVd3Z'z oVø!BQ,ojmӸ6MӦ/?i MUjBy-'ϷV-|3Peōo:PkJe!>X٪bt 2rBj-i}zO脏ʩіkyPA„g0J_z5UjYAQlXPIy nU:{\886aM(;56Q("u^+9Vj9ej0}wZGέRtuԢMnH0Y!e|w8o#ҶD6xh\*[m1)iV!DF| eUJ}|,IZCqy\yYX#@:(Qo6&Q,`Uɧ gٰmNl@v&$HMQ63J$ZkGN! 3)jf6{v A;oW88̞y%KxW{>-%پ|$Ҕ9طu L E2Ivʛ8 !JW QD`~_?fDZfnd\-8z)mqw]WWᚼu[-2,r?xNֶ Ï:YRݚe)\]V^b)Hob*n'ꐬ UuD JB{5eJOr) `*RW "(teN>߭Ŭ:i[hw64_(V4I~Y6o=c.`:n6Fe5^e4fr}ijLjd:g('9~2Z&yW.3+X(Rf$D5a :dLFirl1O=ӸXcl)YFdN;2OcD隷%Rosނ,(bi+X1IO/AԷ| t굍*"YI5@W.͉9ŗf(+ޡ+Jgvqy'QJ#U^XZn}kFbo>)q{nA󐺦Wo@,2 U^6oNT曢"|fnëJafXeY뗽gLYȿa&"xBKB j+Lޟ!TaJgsL[?JE^˼"72Xk@bҪE)F"rt RC~L~Y+Bua J5vH_X:)޻ԚMbO9)(N/nV 8V5RCCjAŧVHK H!VڒZ!$B6zb ^ Ocx>~|dl7b$f|"aKM8ԤBE=+< _'}lʃGe !!iIe)f brk[C {7=릪,n(Ac o3<} ^ xJ^AP SeDsس{SWxr4Vs_-YW ^[hI5Oz)r_*9:Ȋl\s$4[D1噼vDp u h*bq*UAk2R[swlG&{q|hp(g]#cէkVM!)@Ai2+i$GTݠ+s|ԺufEoig"aQȊ Z.ddayϧ~ȯ ȣPN65dh~_b]A*:Uf5䃃JeNJS X0]#JTAkŞ?_9, a%qVڣX _;utieR,dIm^ dEjdCKk̠s'W,@DvEaX"aJpe}(ꪍm-_Wu%{rpV<.NJ6q3x$5DHÝ%綽-RȖ k2~]&гE5 ENJZ"ʒ#*\N遡28J8ةHs6 @B0)lꇪ݆Q}ij =R8[\=>ޱy01l?V-c䯯֝kZk&%(m2׺.8tAEGfNBMN6(tPJ@ @ @@@@@`@```@@@@ @ @ @ @@ @ @ ` @` ` ` @ @ @ @ @@@@@ @@ @ @ @@@@@@@@@@`@@`@`@`@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@@`@``` `@ ` ` `@`@@`@`@```@```````@````@````@````@```@ @ @@@@@`@```@@@@@ @ @@@@@`@```@@@@@ @ @@@@@`@```@@@@@ @ @@@@@`@```@@@@ ja ѥ w a -aAᐁ AwAᶡ- (wwba aAbew) 1. ᠡi e ja baba a aA (Robert Brenner) 4Ewi wA: A A ae 嬥a 1950-1998e4 (e w a⸥ bЉ New Left Review 1998e 5/6 ɥa AAa)i ŵbe a. a aAe ġ͡a b (UCLA) bab a aA (Old Brenner Debate)a e 1970eA 币E AA a i e ba 鐡 iaa a. aa w Ae aA Aʼn sʗA e Ё e A jae A Aa eA aa aΡ eA a. a aAi babae i aqie aa A 币 a AwA eA e we wAb i iae i ⸡ gA va. aСe aAa a wA ai 币 eֵae a, aa baba A a á e(Solidarity) a a Against the Current wA eс wA AA ʼne a i ia΁ ֵae a wi qeeae, A iaE AwAᶡ e {e aAᐁ eii Aa AaС i we ሡwA Ɂaa i Ɂ e a i a. iAe w i ia͡, eE Aa 币A e ea aA (New Brenner Debate) a ii qa, A e ai i a ea. 2. aAᐁ AwAᶡ wA 1970e aA A aAe w e sʗ ai a AA a i wi i wa. aA aAe AwAᶡi a Ae aa ae sʗ aa a ae w wi a 币 a ᶡi wi i waa ae sʗA ѥA e ei Aa. aAe A w EI aХA baa A2a A币 AiA ae eA e AwA w ᶡA e ɉ ᬉi aС a. aAe 币 AwA w ᶡi EI i a ea. aAe 币 qe 1965-1973ei w AeA a e EI aA a wea. EI ai AwAᶡ a qa aAe a i 鬁 b˷ᴡe a ja ѥ waA iea. aAe w bA aa 4ḡw 󴡷 eaeA, wA A EI wwi aa ae Ai, 4ḡw 󴁷 A e, 4w 󴁷 …e Aʉ ( )A xea. b 4w e a a A (w) A, 4ḡw 󴁷 A aС, AaA wEEIi Bbi e e, AaС gaa, aA e EI aeae a. aAe EI aЁ i wA xeae A, ae EI a , b EI aЁ i a A eAe a A (e A e ia e ‰)A xe eai(Fundamentalists)a, ai qwwA ae Esb e e A xe aa ѥ 鸡 (e aA ⸁) iEa. b aAᐁ EI a e ae a EI a aea EI ai с a eaСe, EI aЁ i ae A w ba e 鬡4e wA e abA e aw sbA xea. ei weae Ae Aae e, e a b aa ae A wi waС, с i e aAa aa eA E abA e aw sb a iᬁ EI aA xeae A ea iEa. `